Prosecutors drop murder charge due to DNA transference

In 2012, a millionaire was robbed, bounded and suffocated. According to the San Jose Mercury News, a homeless man’s DNA was found under the victim’s fingernail, and the man was arrested on a murder charge. However, his attorney was able to prove that not only did the man not commit the crime, but he was never even at the scene. A paramedic had accidentally transferred the man’s DNA to the location of the incident.

While the case may be the first of its kind, it is certainly not the only situation in which faulty DNA evidence has resulted in inaccurate charges and even wrongful convictions.

Building a strong defense

In the case of the homeless man, the prosecution built an argument based on the fact that the man had a history of both violent and nonviolent crimes. Additionally, the homeless man had a brain injury that caused memory issues, and he was unable to recall where he was the night of the murder. Combined with the DNA at the scene of the crime, it appeared the prosecution had a compelling case.

However, the defendant’s attorney discovered that on the night of the murder, the man was taken to a medical facility after he had passed out in an urban area. The same monitoring device that was placed on his finger was later put onto the victim’s finger, thus transferring the DNA. Upon reviewing the evidence, the prosecution dropped the charges.

The problems with DNA

The American Psychological Association points out that for as helpful as DNA evidence can be when solving crimes, it also presents a number of opportunities for mistakes, inaccuracies and exaggeration. As in the case of the homeless man, it is possible for DNA to be transferred from one location to another, misleading investigators, juries and judges to believe that someone was at a scene.

Other common issues related to DNA include the following:

  • The statistics – DNA matches are rarely perfect, meaning there are only odds that the DNA at a scene matches the DNA of the suspect. Therefore, it is possible for samples to match each other solely by coincidence.
  • Human error – Lab technicians often evaluate the samples in order to determine their validity and can make mistakes.
  • Mixed samples – Due to improper storage or contamination, a DNA sample could contain evidence from different sources, further complicating the identification process.

A study published in Psychological Science suggests that for every 100 samples, labs produce at least one or two false positive matches. Anyone with questions regarding the fallibility of DNA evidence should consult with a felony defense attorney.

Max Keller has won countless jury trial cases involving misdemeanors and felonies, sex crimes, and DWI’s. He is a member of the Minnesota Society for Criminal Justice, which only allows the top 50 criminal defense attorneys in the state as members. Max is a frequent speaker at CLE’s and is often asked for advice by other defense attorneys across Minnesota.

Years of Experience: Approx. 20 years
Minnesota Registration Status: Active
Bar & Court Admissions: State of Minnesota Minnesota State Court Minnesota Federal Court 8th Circuit Federal Court of Appeals State of Maryland

What to Do If You Have Been Charged with a Criminal Offense

Understanding Solicitation and Enticement Laws in Minnesota

Recently, a sex sting operation in Bloomington, Minnesota, led to the arrest of at least 14 men, including former Minnesota Senator Justin Eichorn. The operation involved undercover officers posing as minors online, engaging with individuals who sought to solicit sexual conduct. 

Accused of Criminal Sexual Conduct at a Minnesota College? What You Need to Know

You will go through a disciplinary hearing if you have been accused of criminal sexual conduct at a Minnesota college. The college disciplinary board will conduct the hearing under Title IX law. This federal law requires learning institutions to investigate and resolve student sexual misconduct separately from concurrent or related criminal proceedings. The college administration will punish you appropriately if the hearing determines that you contravened the sexual consent policies under the college’s Code of Conduct. The punishment can range from suspension and college-imposed probationary period to expulsion and compulsory sexual education classes.

Busted at a Music Festival? What Happens If You’re Caught With Club Drugs in Minnesota

One question you may ask when planning to attend an upcoming music festival is: What happens if I’m caught with club drugs in Minnesota? The legal consequences of getting busted with drugs at a music festival include an arrest, criminal charges, a fine, and imprisonment. Beyond the legal consequences, a drug crime charge or conviction can lower your chances of securing employment, housing, and student loans. It may also strain your relationships with family, friends, and society.