New Ruling Allows Police to Search Phones Without Warrant

To the possible dismay of criminal defense and constitutional law attorneys across the United States, a California judge ruled Monday that police in the state of California may search an arrested individual’s phone. The ruling allows police to search any data that is kept on an arrested person’s phone. Under the ruling data is considered to include texts, emails, photos, web browsing history, address books or other data stored on the phone. The ruling only affects California law.

The new ruling was given on Monday by a Superior Court judge in Ventura County, California. In explaining the ruling, the judge issuing the opinion said that an individual’s right to privacy is lost upon arrest and the loss of privacy is extended to include personal property “immediately associated with the person of the arrestee at the time of the arrest.”

The ruling stems from a 2007 drug deal case. A Ventura County Sheriff witnessed a drug deal that involved a car driven by a suspect. The suspect and his passenger were arrested and six pills of Ecstasy were obtained. The arrested driver was taken to a police station and his phone was seized. The driver denied any involvement with the drug deal during his interview with police. A police deputy then reviewed text messages contained on the phone and found one message that said “6 4 80” which the officer interpreted to mean “Six pills of Ecstasy for $80.” The deputy then challenged the driver’s previous story and showed him the text message. The driver then admitted to the drug deal.

The ruling allows police in California to review any data stored on an arrested person’s phone including voicemails, chat conversations and more. Responding to the decision, a representative from the American Civil Liberties Union said that it is unclear whether police can copy information from an arrested person’s phone and that police cannot force an individual to unlock their phone without a judge’s order.

Source: CNN, “Ruling Lets California Police Search Your Phone Without a Warrant,” Amy Gahran, 1/5/11

Max Keller has won countless jury trial cases involving misdemeanors and felonies, sex crimes, and DWI’s. He is a member of the Minnesota Society for Criminal Justice, which only allows the top 50 criminal defense attorneys in the state as members. Max is a frequent speaker at CLE’s and is often asked for advice by other defense attorneys across Minnesota.

Years of Experience: Approx. 20 years
Minnesota Registration Status: Active
Bar & Court Admissions: State of Minnesota Minnesota State Court Minnesota Federal Court 8th Circuit Federal Court of Appeals State of Maryland

What to Do If You Have Been Charged with a Criminal Offense

Can Past Allegations of Sex Crimes Be Used Against You in Minnesota?

One question people charged with a sex crime in Minneapolis, MN, ask is: Can past allegations of sex crimes be used against me? Under Minnesota Rules of Evidence, past sex crime allegations aren't admissible as evidence in court to prove a suspect's character and argue that it contributed to the commission of the current crime. However, there are circumstances in which the court may allow prior allegations or bad conduct as evidence. These circumstances include when the prosecution can demonstrate that prior allegations or acts are key to establishing intent, identity, or pattern of bad conduct related to the current crime.

What If The Alleged Victim Was Drunk? Minnesota Consent & Alcohol Laws

Under Minnesota consent & alcohol laws, it is unlawful to engage in sexual contact or intercourse with someone drunk or intoxicated to a degree that prevents that person from consenting, understanding, or keeping his or her actions in check. Simply put, you should avoid sexual contact with a person who visibly looks impaired by alcohol, drugs, or other intoxicating substances.

How Long Do Police Have to File Drug Charges in Minnesota?

People facing arrests or under investigation for drug-related crimes often wonder: How long do police have to file drug charges in Minnesota? Once police officers conclude their investigations and arrest you for drug trafficking, the law bars them from holding you in custody for long. But, even if they can't keep you in jail, the Minnesota statute of limitations allows the prosecution to file the charges within three (3) years of arrest.