The concern with the ‘CSI Effect’

For every criminal case the prosecution and the criminal defense must use the available evidence to demonstrate their case. These days some prosecutors believe that a certain crime show may be making their job more difficult, CSI. Some prosecutors think that the crime show CSI has created a new expectation among jury members. The new expectation is that tests that use high technology should be used to convict defendants. The new trend is referred to as the CSI Effect.

One coroner from Nevada whose office was the basis for CSI says the show has brought benefits and problems to the death investigation process. The benefit is that the public knows more about the death investigation process and the negative aspect is that the public believes a crime can be solved within the time of a television show or that people expect to get a DNA test back in 20 minutes. Prosecutors and legal experts worry that juries are confusing the reality of crime investigations with the fiction they see on television.

But, one judge from Michigan does not put much stock in the CSI Effect. All of the information on the subject he found was not empirical research and was based on the opinions of attorneys. The judge conducted his own investigation on the CSI Effect by conducting a study that surveyed people called for jury duty. The judge and his team interviewed over 2,000 potential jurors on their television preferences and what their expectations were regarding the criminal justice system. The judge concluded jurors expect the use of high technology, but the expectation comes from the use of technology in their everyday lives and not from the television they watch. The judge says placing responsibility on a television show is too simplistic.

Source: NPR, “Is the ‘CSI Effect’ influencing courtrooms?” Arun Rath, 2/6/11

Max Keller has won countless jury trial cases involving misdemeanors and felonies, sex crimes, and DWI’s. He is a member of the Minnesota Society for Criminal Justice, which only allows the top 50 criminal defense attorneys in the state as members. Max is a frequent speaker at CLE’s and is often asked for advice by other defense attorneys across Minnesota.

Years of Experience: Approx. 20 years
Minnesota Registration Status: Active
Bar & Court Admissions: State of Minnesota Minnesota State Court Minnesota Federal Court 8th Circuit Federal Court of Appeals State of Maryland

What to Do If You Have Been Charged with a Criminal Offense

How a DWI Affects CDL Holders in Minnesota

Commercial motor vehicle drivers arrested or charged with driving while impaired (DWI) may need to know how a DWI affects CDL holders in Minnesota. You will lose your Commercial Driver’s License (CDL) for at least a year if you are convicted of DWI for the first time, and forever after a second conviction. The consequences go beyond the immediate legal implications of a DWI conviction. A CDL suspension or revocation will lead to job loss, difficulty finding employment, and serious financial challenges.

How a DWI Affects Rideshare Drivers in Minnesota

Knowing how a DWI affects rideshare drivers in Minnesota allows you to take the right steps to protect your license and livelihood. A DWI conviction will lead to suspension or cancellation of your driver’s license. Once you lose your license, you will be ineligible for a work permit required to work for rideshare companies as a driver. You may also face jail time, fines, or ignition interlock device (IID) installation, depending on the seriousness and number of related offenses on your record.

Can Police Search Your Phone Without a Warrant in Minnesota?

People under criminal investigation or whose phones have been seized by law enforcement officers may ask, “Can police search your phone without a warrant in Minnesota?” It’s illegal for police to search your phone without a warrant. However, there are exceptions to the warrant requirement. These exceptions include when you consent to the search, someone’s life is in danger, or there is an immediate risk of evidence destruction.