Guns, knives, pepper spray, and tasers are legal self-defense weapons in Minnesota. However, while self-defense is legal in our state, it’s also highly regulated. You can use weapons like firearms, knives, pepper spray, and tasers to defend yourself, your loved ones, or your property, but only under specific conditions.
To qualify as lawful self-defense, you must:
- Be legally allowed to possess the weapon.
- Use it only in response to an imminent threat.
- Apply only the amount of force reasonably necessary to stop the attack.
Minnesota law doesn’t give you a free pass to use a weapon in self-defense just because you felt scared. If you’re a felon, underage, or on K-12 school grounds, you may be barred from possessing or using certain weapons, even in self-defense.
Table of Contents
When Is Force Considered Self-Defense in Minnesota?
Minnesota Statutes outline when you’re legally allowed to use force. You’re permitted to use reasonable force to:
- Resist or prevent an offense against your person or property.
- Defend others (children, dependents, spouses, etc.).
- Stop someone from committing a crime.
However, the law draws a hard line: the moment the threat ends, your legal justification ends, too. If you keep attacking after the threat is neutralized, you’ve crossed into assault territory—even if you started in self-defense.
The Fine Line Between Assault and Self-Defense
Self-defense cases rarely come wrapped in a tidy bow. In most real-life scenarios, violence escalates fast, and decisions are made in seconds. The difference between legal self-defense and criminal assault often boils down to:
- Intent
- Immediacy of the threat
- Proportionality of force used
If someone throws a punch, and you respond with a gunshot, expect to be scrutinized heavily—even if you felt endangered. That’s why understanding what Minnesota considers “reasonable” force is essential.
Five Degrees of Assault in Minnesota
Here’s how Minnesota classifies assault charges:
- First Degree Assault – Great bodily harm or risk of death.
- Second Degree – Assault with a deadly weapon.
- Third Degree – Substantial bodily harm; often includes child abuse.
- Fourth Degree – Assault on peace officers, EMTs, or bias-motivated assaults.
- Fifth Degree – The lowest level, often includes threats or attempted harm.
Understanding these distinctions matters, especially when building a self-defense claim. If your force escalates beyond what’s deemed reasonable, your charges can escalate just as quickly.
Is There a Duty to Retreat in Minnesota?
Yes. Minnesota is not a stand-your-ground state. Under Minnesota law, you have a duty to retreat before using force, if retreat is reasonably possible. This means:
- If you can avoid the confrontation without endangering yourself or others, you must.
- If you don’t retreat, even when it’s safe, you risk losing your self-defense argument in court.
Exception: The Castle Doctrine
Minnesota recognizes a limited castle doctrine, which allows you to defend your home (or sometimes your workplace) without retreating. But—and this is critical—the force still must be proportionate.
Case Study: Byron David Smith
The infamous Byron David Smith case tested this doctrine. Smith shot and killed two teenagers who broke into his home. While the court agreed he didn’t have to retreat, it also found he used excessive force—shooting the teens after they were no longer a threat. He was convicted of murder.
Lesson: Just because you’re in your home doesn’t mean you can kill indiscriminately. The moment the threat is gone, continued force is no longer justified.
Legal Self-Defense Weapons in Minnesota: What’s Allowed?
Here’s a breakdown of commonly used self-defense weapons and their legal standing:
- Firearms: Legal, must have valid permit, no felons, cannot be used on school property.
- Knives: Legal if not used with intent to harm unlawfully. Switchblades are banned.
- Pepper Spray: Legal if used in self-defense. Must be 16 years old or older, no felons.
- Tasers: Legal, must be 18 years old or older, no felons, must be used strictly for defense.
Using these weapons in a manner that doesn’t align with state law, especially if the attack doesn’t justify the level of force, can get you charged, not protected.
What Is “Reasonable Force”?
“Reasonable” doesn’t mean “whatever you feel like.” Courts will examine:
- The threat level: Was the attacker armed?
- Your response: Did you use just enough force to stop the threat?
- The outcome: Did your response escalate the violence?
For example, if someone shoves you in a bar, and you respond by stabbing them, expect to be charged, no matter how aggressive they were. But if someone brandishes a weapon or enters your home uninvited, a strong self-defense argument is more likely to hold up.
Pepper Spray and International Headlines
The debate around legal self-defense isn’t just domestic. In 2016, a 17-year-old girl in Denmark used pepper spray to fend off a rapist, and she was nearly fined because pepper spray is banned there. This case ignited global debate around how much force is “too much” when your life is at risk.
Here in the U.S., pepper spray is legal in all 50 states, but several states (like New York, Massachusetts, California, and Wisconsin) restrict who can carry it and how it’s used.
In Minnesota, you can legally carry pepper spray if:
- You’re over 16.
- You don’t have a felony record.
- You use it strictly for self-defense.
Still, if you spray someone who was walking away, expect legal consequences.
Call a Lawyer
Self-defense laws in Minnesota offer protection, but not immunity. Whether you used a taser or a firearm, the moment you pull a weapon, the law will ask tough questions about why, how, and when you acted.
Don’t try to navigate that gray area alone. If you’re facing charges after defending yourself, consult a Minneapolis criminal defense lawyer at our law firm immediately. Your freedom could depend on how well you can prove that your actions were legally justified.
At Keller Criminal Defense Attorneys in Minneapolis and St. Paul, we offer free consultations to people who have been charged with a crime. Call us at 952-913-1421.
