Three types of witness testimony in a criminal case are eyewitness, character, and expert witness testimony. The statements these individuals provide can sway a judge or jury, strengthen legal arguments, and ultimately influence whether a defendant walks free or ends up behind bars. Whether you’re facing criminal charges or building a defense strategy, understanding the role each witness plays is crucial to protecting your rights and freedom.
In most criminal trials, both the prosecution and defense call witnesses to support their version of events. The prosecutor may use witnesses to try to establish guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Your criminal defense attorney, meanwhile, may call witnesses to challenge those claims, highlight inconsistencies, or present an entirely different perspective.
Not all witnesses are equal. Each witness category serves a different function in court, providing insight, context, or technical details that can shape how the facts are interpreted. Even one statement from the right (or wrong) witness can change the outcome of a case.
Table of Contents
What Is Witness Testimony in a Criminal Case?
Witness testimony in a criminal case is a statement given under oath by someone with knowledge relevant to the case. It may be delivered in court, through an affidavit, or during a deposition. Witnesses are required to tell the truth and may be questioned by both the prosecution and defense.
People who give witness testimony may include:
- Eyewitnesses who saw the event take place, including victims of the alleged crime
- Character witnesses familiar with the defendant’s behavior
- Expert witnesses with professional knowledge on a relevant subject
Before trial, attorneys typically prepare witnesses by reviewing their expected testimony, explaining the legal process, and discussing how to respond during cross-examination.
Why Witnesses Are Critical to a Criminal Trial
In a criminal trial, witness testimony is often the most powerful form of evidence presented in court. The types of witnesses in a criminal case—eyewitnesses, expert witnesses, and character witnesses—can support the prosecution’s case or help the defense disprove allegations. Their credibility, knowledge, and firsthand accounts can sway the outcome of a trial, making witness strategy a critical part of any defense.
Most witnesses are subpoenaed to appear in court and testify under oath. What they say may directly impact whether a judge or jury finds a defendant guilty or not guilty. In many cases, witness testimony is the only evidence available.
Types of Witnesses in Criminal Cases
Eyewitnesses
An eyewitness is someone who personally observed the alleged crime or events surrounding it. They may have seen the crime unfold, identified the people involved, or witnessed what happened before or after the incident. Their testimony can provide a direct link between the defendant and the crime.
However, eyewitness accounts aren’t always reliable. Stress, poor lighting, fear, or bias can affect memory. That’s why attorneys often compare statements from multiple witnesses to identify inconsistencies or validate key facts.
Eyewitness Eligibility
To testify, an eyewitness must:
- Understand the nature of an oath or promise to tell the truth
- Be capable of providing oral or written statements
In Minnesota, children under 14 can testify if they understand the need to tell the truth and can answer questions clearly. Individuals with cognitive impairments may also testify, provided they commit to being truthful.
Expert Witnesses
An expert witness provides specialized knowledge that helps the court understand complex issues beyond the average person’s understanding. These witnesses commonly include:
- Psychologists and psychiatrists
- Medical doctors
- Forensic analysts
- Handwriting or fingerprint experts
- Accident reconstructionists
Their opinions are based on scientific research, published studies, professional training, and real-world experience. Courts typically treat their testimony as highly credible.
Expert Witness Requirements
To qualify, an expert witness must:
- Have specialized education, training, or experience
- Be relevant to the specific facts of the case
- Be necessary to explain technical matters to the judge or jury
- Meet legal standards for admissibility under Minnesota rules of evidence
The judge ultimately decides whether an expert is competent to testify.
Character Witnesses
A character witness offers insight into the defendant’s behavior, moral standards, and reputation. These witnesses are usually family members, friends, employers, or community members who know the defendant well.
Their testimony is often used to support a defense based on credibility or to humanize the defendant during sentencing. In cases involving fraud, theft, or violent behavior, character evidence can help tip the balance toward leniency.
What a Character Witness Can Testify To
Character witnesses:
- Do not need formal qualifications
- May only speak to the defendant’s general reputation, not specific acts
- Typically explain their relationship to the defendant, then discuss traits like honesty, integrity, or peacefulness
Is Witness Testimony Considered Evidence?
Yes. Witness testimony is a legal form of evidence, and in some cases, it’s the only evidence a jury or judge hears. As long as the testimony is provided under oath and not successfully challenged, the court treats it as credible.
However, opposing counsel can question a witness’s accuracy or truthfulness. Cross-examination, physical evidence, or prior inconsistent statements may be used to impeach a witness’s credibility. In the end, the judge or jury weighs the value of that testimony based on the facts presented.
Why Legal Representation Matters in Cases Involving Witnesses
An experienced Minnesota criminal defense attorney doesn’t just listen to witness testimony—they strategically manage every aspect of it to strengthen your defense and protect your rights.
Here’s how an attorney can influence the outcome through witness-related tactics:
- Investigating Prosecution Witnesses: Your lawyer will dig into the background of each witness the state plans to call. This includes checking for bias, prior inconsistent statements, criminal records, and motives to lie.
- Suppressing or Discrediting Testimony: If a witness was improperly influenced, coached, or their statements were obtained unlawfully, your attorney may file a motion to exclude their testimony from trial.
- Identifying the Right Defense Witnesses: Based on the charges and the facts of your case, your lawyer will determine whether to call character witnesses, alibi witnesses, or experts who can explain forensic or psychological evidence.
- Preparing Witnesses for Court: A skilled defense attorney will prepare your witnesses for direct and cross-examination. They’ll ensure your witnesses are credible, confident, and legally sound.
- Leveraging Witness Weaknesses in Negotiations: If the prosecution’s case hinges on shaky or contradictory testimony, your attorney can use that to push for reduced charges, favorable plea deals, or even case dismissal.
If you’re accused of a crime, don’t assume the facts will speak for themselves—witnesses are often the loudest voice in the courtroom. An attorney who understands how to challenge, prepare, and present witnesses can shift the balance in your favor.
