Minnesota man scoots out of scooter DWI charges on appeal

Occasionally you might hear about someone getting picked up for a DWI while driving a lawnmower or some other type of recreational vehicle; however one Minnesota man made it into the headlines when he was arrested for a DWI while riding on a personal mobility scooter.

According to news reports, the man drove his mobility scooter to a nearby car lot. He claimed that he was looking for a vehicle for his girlfriend. One of the employees at the car dealership allegedly called the police to report the presence of an intoxicated man on the property. When the police arrived at the car lot, the man was given a breath test. The results of the test indicated that the man’s alcohol concentration (a.k.a. BAC) was 0.17. The legal limit in Minnesota and every other state is 0.08.

The man was arrested and charged with a DWI. He appealed the conviction on the grounds that he was not driving a “vehicle” within the scope of the Minnesota DWI statute. Under the law, a “vehicle” is “any vehicle which is self-propelled except for an electric personal mobility device.” Since the man was operating such a personal mobility device (a motorized wheelchair or scooter) at the time of his arrest, he could not be charged with operating a “vehicle” under the influence of alcohol.

The judges who heard the man’s appeal agreed with this line of reasoning and reversed his DWI conviction. Essentially, under Minnesota law, an electric scooter is classified as a wheel chair. Therefore, the man was technically functioning as a pedestrian rather than a driver at the time of his arrest.

The defendant’s response to the court following his legal victory: “I’ll be danged. You just made my day.”

Source

Pioneer Press: “Disabled man on scooter won’t get DWI,” Emily Gurnon, 14 Jun. 2011

Max Keller has won countless jury trial cases involving misdemeanors and felonies, sex crimes, and DWI’s. He is a member of the Minnesota Society for Criminal Justice, which only allows the top 50 criminal defense attorneys in the state as members. Max is a frequent speaker at CLE’s and is often asked for advice by other defense attorneys across Minnesota.

Years of Experience: Approx. 20 years
Minnesota Registration Status: Active
Bar & Court Admissions: State of Minnesota Minnesota State Court Minnesota Federal Court 8th Circuit Federal Court of Appeals State of Maryland

What to Do If You Have Been Charged with a Criminal Offense

The Surprising Cost of a Guilty Criminal Plea in Minnesota

Defendants in Minnesota may plead guilty or accept deals without understanding the hidden cost of a guilty criminal plea. A guilty criminal plea, regardless of how appealing it appears, can leave you dealing with substantial lifelong consequences. You may skip lengthy trial proceedings and likely get a lenient sentence, but end up with a criminal record. The record can lead to various financial and collateral consequences, including difficulty in securing employment, loss of housing rights, license revocation, and immigration issues.

What You Can Expect at a Pre-Trial Motions Hearing in Minnesota

The pre-trial motions hearing is a court session you attend after your first arraignment. At the hearing, the prosecution and defense appear before a judge to clear several details about the case before trial. These details include pre-trial motions, evidentiary queries, and constitutional matters.

Refusing Arrest vs. Resisting Arrest in Minnesota: What’s the Difference?

Highly publicized incidents of police using excessive force over the past few years have led to people wondering, “What’s the difference between refusing arrest vs. resisting arrest?” Resisting arrest in Minnesota occurs when you use force to prevent a police officer from making a lawful arrest. Refusing an arrest, on the other hand, involves statements or actions that show reluctance to cooperate with an officer’s instructions without using force.